Top 5 Italian Restaurants in Melbourne: A Local's Guide to Authentic Dining
Discover Melbourne's finest Italian dining experiences with our curated guide to the city's top Italian restaurants. From handmade pasta specialists to authentic Sicilian cuisine, learn where locals go for genuine flavours, exceptional service, and memorable meals across various budgets and vibes.
Melbourne's love affair with Italian cuisine runs deep, creating one of the most vibrant Italian food scenes outside of Italy itself. From the historic laneways of the CBD to the bustling streets of Carlton and beyond, authentic Italian restaurants have become integral to Melbourne's renowned culinary landscape. What makes a great Italian restaurant in Melbourne experience isn't just about the food—it's about the passion, traditions, and stories behind each venue.
This guide celebrates the diversity of flavours through five exceptional venues: from intimate pasta bars to family-run trattorias that have become local institutions. Whether you're craving perfectly al dente handmade pasta, wood-fired Neapolitan pizza, or innovative Italian-Australian fusion, these restaurants represent the best of what Melbourne has to offer.
Tipo 00
361 Little Bourke St, Melbourne VIC 3000, Australia
Specialising in handmade pasta, this establishment offers dishes like squid ink tagliolini and porcini mushroom gnocchi, crafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients.
Figlia
335 Lygon St, Brunswick East VIC 3057, Australia
This Brunswick East gem offers a menu that blends traditional and inventive Italian dishes, from tempura eggplant to pippies with nduja.
Umberto Espresso Bar
917 High St, Thornbury VIC 3071, Australia
A Thornbury favourite, this cosy spot captures the essence of a traditional Italian eatery with a focus on hearty, home-style dishes.
Bar Idda
132 Lygon St, Brunswick East VIC 3057, Australia
Specialising in Sicilian cuisine, this Brunswick East spot offers dishes like slow-cooked lamb shoulder and crispy arancini.
Johnny, Vince & Sam’s
306-308 Lygon St, Carlton VIC 3053, Australia
Located on Lygon Street, this restaurant offers a fun twist on Italian dining, blending traditional recipes with a lively atmosphere.
Conclusion
Melbourne's Italian restaurant scene offers incredible diversity, from the refined pasta artistry of Tipo 00 to the homely Sicilian flavours of Bar Idda. What makes these five venues special is their commitment to authenticity while embracing local produce and Melbourne's unique culinary identity. Each restaurant tells its own story through food, creating experiences that go beyond just a meal.
Have you visited any of these Italian gems? We'd love to hear about your favourite dishes or if you have other Italian restaurants in Melbourne that deserve recognition. The beauty of Melbourne's Italian food scene is that there's always another hidden gem waiting to be discovered.
If you're looking to explore more of Melbourne's vibrant food scene beyond Italian cuisine, spotfynda can help you discover venues perfectly matched to your preferences, whether you're planning a romantic date night, a family celebration, or a casual catch-up with mates.
Find Your Perfect Venue with spotfynda
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need to make reservations at these Italian restaurants?
Absolutely. Tipo 00 is notoriously difficult to book, requiring 4-6 weeks advance reservation for weekends and 2-3 weeks for weeknights. Bar Idda needs 1-2 weeks notice, while Umberto Espresso Bar, Figlia, and Johnny, Vince & Sam's should be booked 3-5 days ahead, especially for Friday and Saturday evenings. For groups or special occasions, book even earlier. Last-minute diners might try Figlia's limited walk-in tables right at opening (5:30pm) or bar seating at Tipo 00 and Johnny, Vince & Sam's during off-peak hours, though this is never guaranteed.
What dietary options are available at these Italian restaurants?
Most of these venues offer vegetarian options, with Figlia and Tipo 00
particularly accommodating with their plant-based dishes. For gluten-free requirements, ring venues directly as many can adapt certain dishes. Umberto Espresso Bar and Johnny, Vince & Sam's are known to be particularly flexible with dietary requirements when notified in advance.
What's the best way to get to these restaurants in Melbourne?
For CBD locations like Tipo 00, public transport is ideal with trams running along Bourke Street. For the Lygon Street venues (Figlia, Bar Idda, Johnny, Vince & Sam's), trams 1 and 6 provide convenient access. Paid parking is available but can be limited, especially during peak hours. For Umberto Espresso Bar in Thornbury, the 86 tram or Thornbury station are your best options.
What price range should I expect for a meal at these Italian restaurants?
Prices vary across these venues. Figlia offers excellent value with most mains under $25. Mid-range options like Umberto Espresso Bar, Bar Idda, and Johnny, Vince & Sam's typically cost $60-80 per person including a glass of wine. Tipo 00 is more premium at approximately $80-120 per person for a complete dining experience with drinks.
What are the signature dishes I shouldn't miss at these Italian restaurants?
Don't miss the squid ink tagliolini at Tipo 00, the Cavolo Nero pizza at Figlia, the daily pasta specials at Umberto Espresso Bar, the slow-cooked lamb shoulder at Bar Idda, and the Neapolitan pizzas at Johnny, Vince & Sam's. Many chefs also offer seasonal specials worth exploring beyond the regular menu.
Discover Your Perfect Spot
Ready to find your own hidden gems? Use spotfynda to discover unique venues based on your preferences.